Why I Picked Matte White Subway Tile for my Kitchen Backsplash

Choosing Kitchen Backsplash
Our kitchen reno is in full swing! As you know, we decided to quickly overhaul our kitchen before moving into our new house. Choosing a backsplash tile for our kitchen was one of the easier decisions for me, so I thought I’d write about it! Here’s why we picked matte white subway tile for our kitchen backsplash.
White subway tile was something I knew I wanted from the get-go. To me, it exudes simplicity, a modern-yet-classic feel, and the right amount of attention. It commands attention, without taking too much. I’ve always liked white kitchens and to me white subway tile is one of the key elements.

Is it OKAY to be Basic?
However, I know that subway tile is extremely over-done right now and at the point of being labeled “basic”. So here’s some practical reasons why I chose it.
- The look. All the aesthetic elements that I mentioned above (simple, classic, etc.)
- Broad appeal. I wanted to consider resale value of our house when renovating the kitchen. I didn’t want to pick a backsplash that some folks might not like years down the road.
- Cost. A huge plus is the fact that subway tile is standard tile and therefore inexpensive. I got mine from Floor & Decor here in Denver and for 3 boxes I paid $150 total.
- Variety. There are a ton of different colors and finishes of subway tile out there. I chose a matte finish to enhance the modern feel of the tiles.

Unbasic
To make my subway tile feel less basic, I chose a medium-gray grout color to go with it. I like the subtle contrast of the grout and the white tile. This makes the subway tile feel like a statement rather than a thoughtless choice.
What do you think of white subway tile? Are you SO over it? I’m curious. So tell me below!
14 Replies to “Why I Picked Matte White Subway Tile for my Kitchen Backsplash”
What did you use for the bullnose?
Hi,
Are you referring to the top edge of the tile where there are no cabinets above it? I believe it’s a white tile trim. It has a squared edge instead of a rounded edge like many do. My installer brought it so I’m not sure exactly where it came from.
I think it’s something like this: https://www.flooranddecor.com/tile-metal-trims-transitional-pieces-installation-materials/schluter-jolly-edge-trim-1-2in.-in-bright-white-color-coated-aluminum-100182971.html
-Misty
Thanks! I also mean on the end. Since there’s no bullnose tile I’m concerned with it looking uneven.
The sides of my tile end in a wall on both ends. So I didn’t have to choose a bullnose. Sorry I’m no help on that.
-Misty
What size spacing did you use?
Hi Jeff,
Thanks for asking. The grout space between tiles is 5 millimeters. Let me know if you have any other questions!
Best,
Misty
Hi Misty,
I totally agree with you about white subway tile, can you please tell me which model or item number did you get from Floor and Décor? or if you have a link will be helpful, i am going crazy with all the options.
Hi Patzi!
Let me know if this link works for you: https://www.flooranddecor.com/porcelain-ceramic-decoratives/meringue-ii-matte-ceramic-tile-100655307.html
I hope that is what you are looking for!
What color grout did you use? I bought the same tile and I’m trying to pick the right gray.
Hi Chelsea,
The grout color we used was Mapei Keracolor’s “Silver” color. It was a bit too dark for my taste. I would recommend a shade lighter.
Hope this helps!
Misty
Assuming your counter top is polished, the matte finish if the tile helps create more depth in the space
Hi Gary,
Apologies for the delayed response. I do believe the counter top is polished. Yes, the matte finish of the tiles helps create dimension!
What size tile did you use?
Hey Liz,
That’s a good question. The tile I used is 12 inches long and 3 inches wide. “Classic” subway tile is 6 inches long and 3 inches wide. Both are good choices!